
The court enforces what the regulators do not.
There is a quiet irony in the way property insurance disputes end in Missouri. A policyholder buys a promise, pays for it faithfully year after year, suffers a loss the policy was written to cover, and then — after months of delay, a denial, or a payment that does not come close to the cost of repair — must hire a lawyer and ask a court to order the insurer to do the very thing the contract already obligated it to do. When the court finally does so, the outcome is treated in some quarters as evidence that litigation has run amok. I would suggest the opposite. Every one of those judgments is a receipt, and the receipt records a promise that was not kept until a judge insisted upon it.
I do not dispute that litigation carries cost, and I will concede the narrow point openly. The Missouri Department of Commerce and Insurance has warned this year of a “strain on the state’s insurance market” and has described a problem it calls “lawsuit abuse.” Lawsuits are expensive, they are slow, and their cost is ultimately borne by all of us in the premiums we pay. On that much, there is no argument. Where I part company is on cause. A courthouse crowded with policyholders seeking to enforce their own contracts is not the disease. It is the symptom of two failures that occur long before anyone files suit, and both of those failures are correctable without a single new statute.
The first is the simplest to state. Insurers could pay their claims. A property policy is not a wager, and it is not a starting position for negotiation; it is a promise to indemnify, and the measure of that promise is the cost to make the insured whole, not the lowest figure an adjuster believes a policyholder will accept before exhaustion sets in. When the promise is honored — when the scope reflects the actual damage, when the estimate reflects the actual cost of repair, when payment follows proof of loss rather than trailing it by months — there is nothing left for a court to enforce. The litigation the Department worries about does not arise from policyholders who were paid what they were owed. It arises, in claim after claim that crosses my desk, from denials that dissolve the moment they are examined, from “functional” damage that is somehow never quite covered, and from delay deployed not as diligence but as strategy. Honor the contract and the courthouse empties.
The second failure belongs to the regulator, and I raise it with respect for the office and its authority. Missouri already requires insurers to acknowledge a claim promptly, to accept or deny it within a defined period, and to pay a satisfactory proof of loss within a fixed number of days. The Department already possesses the power to examine claims practices, to demand records, and to discipline carriers that handle claims unfairly. These are not powers that must be created; they are powers that must be exercised. It is a curious thing to watch an agency announce, with justified pride, that it recovered more than one hundred twenty-nine million dollars for consumers in a single year, and that more than two and nine-tenths billion dollars was paid statewide in the year following our last catastrophic storm season, and then, in the same season, characterize the enforcement of contracts through the courts as an abuse. Those recoveries did not materialize because the claims process worked as designed. They materialized because someone — a public adjuster, a lawyer, a persistent policyholder — refused to accept the first answer. Each recovery is proof that the front end of the process is not being policed as firmly as the back end is being celebrated.
I write from a particular vantage point. As a public adjuster, I am retained by people who have already been told no, or told “this much and not a penny more,” by carriers who wrote the policy, priced the risk, and collected the premium. I do not take routine claims that were fairly resolved, because there is no work for me there and no wrong to correct. The cases that reach me are the ones the system was supposed to prevent, and they reach me because the two safeguards that should have stopped them — the insurer’s own obligation to pay, and the regulator’s obligation to watch — did not hold. When those safeguards hold, my telephone is quiet and the docket is short. When they do not, the dispute travels the long and expensive road to a courtroom, and we are then invited to blame the road.
So let us be precise about what Missouri courts are actually doing. They are not manufacturing obligations; they are confirming ones that already existed in black and white. They are the last line of a promise, not the first. If we are troubled by how many disputes now end there — and we should be — the remedy is not to make the courthouse harder for policyholders to reach. The remedy is to make it unnecessary. Insurers can do that by paying what the policy requires, when the policy requires it. Regulators can do that by using the authority they already hold to see that insurers do. Do those two things, and the litigation the Department fears will recede on its own, because there will be nothing left to litigate.
A contract honored needs no judge. A process watched needs no lawsuit. The courthouse only fills when the two rooms upstairs are left empty.
James H. Bushart is a Missouri Licensed Public Adjuster and Senior Claim Law Associate. He represents policyholders in disputed and underpaid property claims. Visit his website.

