
For years I have written on this site that an engineer hired by an insurance company is not working for you. That was an argument.
In November 2026 it became a measurement.
What Oklahoma did
The Oklahoma Insurance Department ran a targeted examination of how State Farm Fire and Casualty Company handled wind and hail roof claims. The Department retained its own examiners, and the examiners retained their own engineers.
Then they did something that almost never happens in a property claim. They sent those engineers back up onto roofs that State Farm had already closed without paying — and they did not tell the engineers what State Farm had decided.
The examination report says so plainly. To avoid “introducing bias to the inspection process the engineering firms had no access to Company claim” files, and information was not “disclosed to the engineering firms by the Examiners or OID staff.”
The engineers went up blind. They did not know what answer they were supposed to reach.
What they found
Fifty-eight homeowners agreed to let the state’s engineer look at their roof. The engineers reported:
- 23 — no storm-related damage
- 8 — roof damage, but they could not tie it to a particular storm
- 14 — storm damage, repair warranted
- 13 — storm damage, replacement warranted
Twenty-seven of fifty-eight roofs needed repair or replacement. Every one of those claims had been closed without payment.
Then the examiners asked the engineering firm to price the work — not at today’s prices, but at “prevailing costs at the time of the Company’s claims determination.” Priced back to the day the decision was made, 22 of those 27 estimates came in above the homeowner’s deductible.
A smaller screen in 2024 had already pointed the same way. Of 14 valid, unrepaired roofs inspected then, 12 contradicted the company’s own claim notes and decisions.
Commissioner Glen Mulready adopted the examination report by order on November 10, 2026. The order states that in at least 22 instances the company failed, in the report’s own words, to “attempt[] in good faith to effectuate prompt, fair and equitable settlement of claims submitted in which liability has become reasonably clear.” A settlement followed two days later: a minimum of $35 million for consumer restitution, $10 million to an Oklahoma home-resiliency grant program, and $2.86 million in fines and examination costs.
State Farm disputes the examination’s findings and denies any violation of law or wrongdoing. It admitted nothing. It also agreed not to appeal the order.
Three things worth taking from this
1. The same roof produced two opposite answers
Nothing about those 27 roofs changed between the first inspection and the second. The shingles were the same shingles.
What changed was who retained the inspector, and what the inspector was allowed to know.
That is the part I want to be precise about, because it is easy to get wrong. The people who found that damage were engineers. A licensed engineering firm went up on those roofs and documented damage warranting repair or replacement. Engineering is not the problem here, and I have never thought it was. If anything, the question worth asking about a report is a narrower one: what is the person who signed it actually qualified in?
The problem is an arrangement in which the person inspecting your roof already knows what his client would prefer to hear, and sees the file that tells him. Change the arrangement and the answers change. That is what this examination measured.
2. There are two inspections, and they are not the same event
When your insurance company sends an adjuster out to look at your damage, be there. Answer the questions. Walk them through what happened and show them what you reported. That is adjusting, and having your claim adjusted is what you pay premiums for. The worst thing that can happen at that visit is that damage you reported never gets looked at — and the way that gets prevented is you, standing there, pointing at it.
Cooperate. Present your claim. That is the stage where presenting it is the whole job.
Then sometimes the company follows its own inspection with an engineer.
That is a different event, and you should treat it differently. The carrier has already had its look. A second look, by an expert it retains and pays, is not more adjusting. By the time an engineer is retained, the file has quietly changed character — from adjusting your claim to building a case against it. The engineer’s report is the instrument of that case. I have watched one of those reports get written around facts that were not true.
So the rule I give policyholders is not “avoid inspections.” It is narrower than that:
Be present and cooperative for the adjuster. Stay away from the engineer.
And not because you have anything to hide. This is worth being clear about, because it is where people misunderstand the advice. The adjuster’s file already contains your account of the loss — you gave it, correctly, at the first inspection — and the engineer will read that file before he arrives. Your absence conceals nothing.
What your absence does is prevent something else: a new, informal, unrecorded interview, conducted on your own property, at the precise moment a case is being assembled against your claim. There is no transcript of that conversation. There is no one there on your side. And whatever you say in it arrives in the report in the engineer’s words, not yours, as support for a conclusion that was commissioned by the other party.
Your obligation at that visit is to provide access to the property. Nothing in your policy obliges you to help prepare the case against your own claim.
One thing has to be true for this to work. By the time the engineer arrives, the record of your loss must already exist — made at the adjuster’s inspection, where you were present and cooperative, and in your own dated photographs taken in the first days after the damage. Staying away from the engineer is safe only because the real record was built earlier, by you, at the right time.
That is the lesson buried in the Oklahoma numbers. Of the 181 claims the state drew, only 58 homeowners responded and let an engineer up on the roof. The other 123 were never inspected at all — and the report describes the effect as “giving the Company the benefit of the doubt of no errors in 67.96% of the sample.” Time had eaten the rest of it: of the first 181 roofs drawn, 26 had already been repaired and 10 of the homes had been sold.
Nobody documented those roofs while there was still something to document. When that happens, the only surviving account of your damage is the one written by the party that decided not to pay for it.
3. The written denial is not always there either
The examination also found that in three instances the company either did not tell the claimant in writing that the claim was being denied, or did not keep a copy of that written denial in the file.
Think about what that means. If your only record of what happened is what you remember saying on your driveway, and the file has no written denial in it, there is nothing. Keep your own copies. Of everything.
What this does and does not mean in Missouri
Let me be careful, because this gets overstated the moment it reaches the internet.
This was Oklahoma. It binds nothing in Missouri and it pays no Missouri policyholder. It is a state insurance regulator’s examination, not a court’s judgment, and no court has found that State Farm did anything wrong. State Farm’s position is that it disputes the findings. The examination also measured the company against a standard concerning whether claim practices push policyholders toward the courthouse, and that was not among the findings it made.
What it does tell you is something about how roof claims get decided, and it comes from a source that is hard to wave away: not a contractor, not a policyholder’s hired expert, not a party to a dispute — a state regulator’s own blind inspections, with the numbers published and the methodology written down.
If your Missouri wind or hail roof claim was denied, closed without payment, or paid at an amount that would not put your roof back, the useful question is not whether anyone can be blamed. The useful question is narrower and much more answerable: what did the inspection actually look at, what did it measure, and what does the report not say?
That is answerable. It is most of what I do.
More on engineer reports: The Improper Use of Engineers to Deny Insurance Claims · Can You Expect an Unbiased Report from Your Insurance Company’s Engineer? · “No Hail Damage” Concluded Before the Roof Inspection? · What “Forensic Engineer” Really Means Under Missouri Law
James H. Bushart is a licensed Missouri public adjuster (License #8207067) and a Senior Claims Law Associate. He is not an attorney and does not give legal advice. He represents home and business owners in denied and underpaid property insurance claims.
Sources: Order Adopting Report of Examination and the attached Report of the Targeted Market Conduct Examination, In re: Examination of State Farm Fire and Casualty Company, Case No. 22-0423-EXM, Oklahoma Insurance Commissioner, November 10, 2026; Settlement Agreement, Case Nos. 26-1372-DIS and 22-0423-EXM, November 12, 2026; Oklahoma Insurance Department news release, November 13, 2026. Documents are published by the Oklahoma Insurance Department at oid.ok.gov.










